Wednesday 27 March 2013

Mini-session analysis, 3rd test, New Zealand England, Eden Park, 2012/3

Here is the final mini-session analysis for the third test between New Zealand and England at Eden Park, Auckland, New Zealand

A mini-session is (normally) half a session, either between the start of the session and the drinks break or the drinks break and the end of the session. Occasionally a long session will have 3 mini-sessions where it will be broken up with 2 drinks breaks.

Mini-SessionScoreWinner
1-1aNew Zealand 31/0 off 15draw
1-1bNew Zealand 48/1 off 13New Zealand
1-2aNew Zealand 48/0 off 15New Zealand
1-2bNew Zealand 46/0 off 16New Zealand
1-3aNew Zealand 36/0 off 13.4New Zealand
1-3bNew Zealand 41/0 off 17.2New Zealand
2-1aNew Zealand 24/1 off 14England
2-1bNew Zealand 38/2 off 14England
2-2aNew Zealand 53/1 off 10.4New Zealand
2-2bNew Zealand 49/1 off 17.2draw
2-3aNew Zealand 29/4 off 6New Zealand
2-3bEngland 50/2 off 25New Zealand
3-1aEngland 22/3 off 11.5New Zealand
3-1bEngland 20/0 off 17.1New Zealand
3-2aEngland 39/0 off 15England
3-2bEngland 45/1 off 14draw
3-3aEngland 28/4 off 6.2New Zealand
3-3bNew Zealand 20/3 off 11England
3-3cNew Zealand 15/0 off 12England
4-1aNew Zealand 47/1 off 12.3New Zealand
4-1bNew Zealand 94/0 off 13.3New Zealand
4-2aNew Zealand 65/2 off 8.2New Zealand
4-2bEngland 45/1 off 16New Zealand
4-3aEngland 32/1 off 20New Zealand
4-3bEngland 13/2 off 16.1New Zealand
5-1aEngland 37/0 off 16.5England
5-1bEngland 31/1 off 14New Zealand
5-2aEngland 41/1 off 13England
5-2bEngland 38/1 off 14.3draw
5-3aEngland 38/0 off 17.3England
5-3bEngland 40/2 off 15New Zealand

Final update, click here
The match is drawn, but New Zealand win the mini-session count 19 - 8

First drinks, Day 1: The mini-session count is tied up, 0-0

A steady, but unspectacular start from New Zealand after being inserted. I do wonder if McCullum was actually foxing about wanting to bowl first.

Lunch, Day 1: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 1-0

A good start by Rutherford and Fulton was soured by a loss of concentration by Rutherford at the end of the session. Still New Zealand are in a good position.

Final drinks, Day 1: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 4-0

England have almost seemed to give up on trying to get a wicket, and are hoping that these two batsmen will get themselves out. Their lines and lengths have not been what should be expected of a test attack. Only Stuart Broad has had the batsmen under any sort of pressure.

Stumps, Day 1: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 5-0

This pitch is not as easy to bat on as these two are making it look. I was watching the majority of that hour from square of the wicket, and the bounce was variable.

First drinks, Day 2: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 5-1

England finally found a way through this partnership. It's the third largest partnership against England in New Zealand, and the third largest 2nd wicket partnership at Eden Park.

Final drinks, Day 2: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 7-2

Southee batting at 8 doesn't make much sense when a team is trying to save a match. In a situation like this, however, it's a great move. He has taken the game to England, and New Zealand now have a respectable first innings score, and much faster than it was looking like.

Stumps, Day 2: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 8-2

Trent Boult picked up two wickets to make it well and truely New Zealand's day. England will need to bat well tomorrow.

First drinks, Day 3: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 9-2

Boult and Southee were in Sri Lanka form this morning. They looked unstopable. England are in serious trouble now.

Lunch, Day 3: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 10-2

20 runs in the hour. While Wagner and Martin didn't make the breakthrough, they certainly kept things tight.

Tea, Day 3: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 10-3

England were looking very good there until Prior made a bad call and played a shot that he will regret. New Zealand now have one end open with the new ball.

Change of innings, Day 3: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 11-3

Trent Boult and Tim Southee finished off the tail. Boult was probably unlucky that Southee dismissed Root at the end, as he would have probably backed himself to pick up Monty fairly quickly and turn 6 into 7. McCullum chose not to enforce the follow on, which seems the right decision to me. It means he gets to chose the heavy roller twice, he gets to give his bowlers a rest and he isn't going to have to bat last on a potentially deteriorating pitch. I'd expect this pitch to take some real turn on the last day and a half.

Final drinks, Day 3: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 11-4

What a disastrous start by New Zealand. Anderson and Borad have combined to leave New Zealand in tatters. England have a serious sniff now. Perhaps McCullum made the wrong call.

Stumps, Day 3: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 11-5

New Zealand see out the day, but what was their day suddenly took a dive at the end. Still New Zealand are in a stronger place at the end of the day than at the start of it. 11 wickets fell again today. This is starting to look very interesting.

First drinks, Day 4: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 12-5

Fulton and Brownlie made some steady progress in the morning. They have gone close to getting New Zealand to safety. Probably New Zealand want about another 80 runs before a lunchtime declaration.

Lunch, Day 4: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 13-5

With Fulton into the 90s, a lunchtime declaration is now probably off the cards. Perhaps once he gets to 100 it will be time to head back?

Middle drinks, Day 4: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 14-5

McCullum took a lot longer to declare than I was expecting, but it might have been due to the runs being so easy to score this morning. The fear that one English batsman would "do an Astle" is probably too strong. Cook is likely to be criticized for his tactics in that hour, but they were sensible, given the situation.

Tea, Day 4: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 15-5

An early breakthrough, and England are looking shaky now. They need a big partnership.

Stumps, Day 4: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 17-5

The thought that Kane Williamson would have provided the vital breakthroughs at the end of the day was quite surprising, but he certainly bowled well. Cook looked furious at himself, while Finn looked like a wicket waiting to happen.

First drinks, Day 5: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 17-6

Solid batting from Root and Bell. New Zealand really need a wicket before lunch, so they can bowl at new batsmen with the new ball.

Lunch, Day 5: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 18-6

The wicket came with the first delivery of the new ball. And there could have been more. First Bairstow survived an lbw shout that turned out to be very close, and then both batsmen were dropped off Boult's second over with the new ball. The big question now is if they will make the most of their lives.

Middle drinks, Day 5: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 18-7

England make steady progress through the day, but New Zealand chip out another one. Prior is living dangerously. His 20 has come off 24 balls, and has included a couple of top edges, some playing and missing, and two very close umpiring calls.

Tea, Day 5: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 18-7

It had started to look like these two were going to see it out, but then Wagner removed Southee to complete the session, and now the impetus is back with New Zealand.

Final drinks, Day 5: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 18-8

Superb from Prior and Broad. This is a big innings for Broad in particular. He has been talked up as a batsman for a long time, here is a chance for him to deliver.

Stumps, Day 5: The match is drawn, but New Zealand take the mini-session count 19-8

A thrilling end, even if somewhat of a let down for the home-town supporters. There was an older gentleman, probably in his late 70's or early 80's sitting a couple of seats along from me. When Anderson was dismissed he was up out of his chair, waving his hand above his head and shouting. No sport creates emotion like a test match. In the end New Zealand didn't do quite enough to win the match. They will rue the dropped catches, as well as the ball hitting Prior's stumps, but not knocking the bails off.

England will probably be more relieved than proud of their effort. Prior stood out like a sore thumb amongst his compatriots, while New Zealand had a number of candidates for an internal man of the match. It's a match that will live on in the memories of everyone who was fortunate enough to have watched it.

Tuesday 26 March 2013

Mini-session analysis 4th test India v Australia, Delhi, 2013

Here is the final mini-session analysis for the fourth test between India and Australia at Feroz Shah Kotla, Delhi

A mini-session is (normally) half a session, either between the start of the session and the drinks break or the drinks break and the end of the session. Occasionally a long session will have 3 mini-sessions where it will be broken up with 2 drinks breaks.

Mini-SessionScoreWinner
1-1aAustralia 47/1 off 14Australia
1-1bAustralia 47/1 off 14Australia
1-2aAustralia 35/4 off 18.2India
1-2bAustralia 24/1 off 20.4India
1-3aAustralia 44/1 off 18draw
1-3bAustralia 34/0 off 13Australia
2-1aAustralia 31/2 off 7Australia
2-1bIndia 59/0 off 14India
2-2aIndia 49/1 off 11.1India
2-2bIndia 24/1 off 12.5Australia
2-3aIndia 73/3 off 13Australia
2-3bIndia 61/3 off 17.1Australia
3-1aIndia 6/2 off 2.1India
Australia 51/3 off 16
3-1bAustralia 38/2 off 15India
3-2aAustralia 68/4 off 13.4India
3-2bAustralia 7/1 off 1.5India
India 72/1 off 12
3-3aIndia 56/3 off 14.4draw
3-3bIndia 30/0 off 4.4India

Final update, click here
India win the match by 6 wickets and the mini-session count 9 - 7


Lunch, Day 1: Australia lead the mini-session count 2-0

A positive start for Australia. They slightly edged both hours. The attacking version of Philip Hughes that was unleashed in the second innings of the last test, and again here, doesn't last any longer than the defensive version, but it's certainly much more fun to watch.

Middle drinks, Day 1: Australia lead the mini-session count 2-1

And like that the game changes. India pick up 4 quick wickets and Australia are placed in a lot of trouble. While they are leading the mini-sesison count, they are well behind in the match now.

Tea, Day 1: The mini-session count is tied up, 2-2

One has to wonder if Australia and New Zealand have swapped teams. New Zealand have batted out a day with only losing one run against England, while Australia are relying on their bowlers for the runs. An almost complete role reversal.

Final drinks, Day 1: The mini-session count is tied up, 2-2

India will be frustrated that they haven't been able to take more than the one wicket this hour.

Stumps, Day 1: Australia lead the mini-session count 3-2

It's India's day, despite them really only being dominant for one hour. But what an hour. Australia will be hoping that Siddle can complete his 50, and they can frustrate the Indian bowlers longer tomorrow. Starc top scored in the last match, and now Siddle in this one. It's almost like watching Northern Districts.

Lunch, Day 2: Australia lead the mini-session count 4-3

Pujara and Vijay are looking relentless. They are scoring at over 4 an over, at the start of the innings against some good bowlers. This match might descend into a real drubbing if this continues.

Middle drinks, Day 2: The mini-session count is tied up, 4-4

A fantastic partnership comes to an end. It was good batting, and it may have set a platform for India to take the match away from Australia here.

Tea, Day 2: Australia lead the mini-session count 5-4

During that hour, the Australian pace bowlers created huge pressure. They conceded 6 runs from 8 overs (4 each from Pattinson and Johnson). That allowed Lyon the pressure to look like a world class spinner. All spin bowlers require pressure to really threaten. This is posibly the first time that Lyon has had that luxury this series.

Final drinks, Day 2: Australia lead the mini-session count 6-4

Now the match gets interesting 73 runs, but 33 wickets. The pressure of the last hour was released, but it came at a significant cost. Australia are back in this match.

Stumps, Day 2: Australia lead the mini-session count 7-4

Another good hour for Australia. Nathan Lyon completed his 5-for and India are now in some difficulty. They lead by 4 with 2 wickets in hand. They are still probably in the better position, but not by much.

First drinks, Day 3: Australia lead the mini-session count 7-5

A good start for Australia, followed by an even better start for India.

Lunch, Day 3: Australia lead the mini-session count 7-6

It looks like the Australians are expecting their bowlers to score the runs again. That worked quite well in the first innings, but I'm not sure it's a good tactic.

Middle drinks, Day 3: The mini-session count is tied up, 7-7

Ravindra Jadeja doesn't look particularly venomous, but he certainly is effective. Australia are in a world of trouble now. They need another big effort from Siddle here to avoid being beaten in 3 days.

Tea, Day 3: India lead the mini-session count 8-7

One has to wonder if Cheteshwar Pujara has a plane to catch. He has approached this run chase as if it was a t20 match. It's very heady batting, as he has denied the bowlers a chance to settle. If they had that opportunity on this pitch then they would have had a chance to bowl Australia into a winning position. It was risky, but it was a risk worth taking.

Final drinks, Day 3: India lead the mini-session count 8-7

Australia are threatening, but India look to be too far ahead. Australia's bowlers have put up a good fight, but their batting was just too inept, and undid all the good work their bowlers did with the bat and ball.

End of match, Day 3: India Win the match by 6 wickets and the mini-session count 9-7

Lyon fell short of his 10 wicket haul, but Siddle managed to join an exclusive group to have been batting on every day of a test. He's also the first number 9 to hit fifties in each innings and to top score in each innings. The last statistic is one that every Australian batsman should hang their heads over. This was a tricky pitch, and the new ball was difficult to navigate, but it wasn't as bad as they made it look. - Mykuhl

Sunday 24 March 2013

Mini-session analysis 2nd test, WI Zim, Rosseau, 2013

Here is the mini-session analysis for the first test between West Indies and Zimbabwe at Windsor Park, Roseau, Dominica

A mini-session is (normally) half a session, either between the start of the session and the drinks break or the drinks break and the end of the session. Occasionally a long session will have 3 mini-sessions where it will be broken up with 2 drinks breaks.

Mini-SessionScoreWinner
1-1aZimbabwe 43/2 off 10.3West Indies
1-1bZimbabwe 50/1 off 16.3draw
1-2aZimbabwe 27/1 off 13West Indies
1-2bZimbabwe 38/3 off 16West Indies
1-3aZimbabwe 17/3 off 4.5Zimbabwe
West Indies 57/2 off 14
1-3bWest Indies 57/0 off 13West Indies
2-1aWest Indies 33/1 off 14Zimbabwe
2-1bWest Indies 54/1 off 17draw
2-2aWest Indies 52/0 off 16West Indies
2-2bWest Indies 42/0 off 16West Indies
2-3aWest Indies 54/0 off 13West Indies
2-3bWest Indies 32/4 off 14Zimbabwe
3-1aZimbabwe 45/1 off 12Zimbabwe
3-1bZimbabwe 32/3 off 14West Indies
3-2aZimbabwe 59/3 off 14.5West Indies
3-2bZimbabwe 5/3 off 1.3West Indies

Final update, click here
West Indies win the mini-session count 10 - 4


Summary West Indies win the match by an innings and 41 runs, and the mini-session count 10-4

I was mocked by a number of people for putting Shane Shillingford into my world test XI at the end of last year. He has again shown why I rate him highly. He takes wickets. Quite a lot of wickets. A few years ago West Indies vs Zimbabwe was quite a close contest. This series shows both how far West Indies have come under Sammy and how far Zimbabwe have fallen in the last 12 years.

Saturday 23 March 2013

Mini-session Analysis 2nd Test, Sri Lanka Bangladesh, Premadasa 2013

Here is the mini-session analysis for the second test between Sri Lanka and Bangladesh at Premadasa Stadium, Colombo, Sri Lanka

A mini-session is (normally) half a session, either between the start of the session and the drinks break or the drinks break and the end of the session. Occasionally a long session will have 3 mini-sessions where it will be broken up with 2 drinks breaks.

Mini-SessionScoreWinner
1-1aBangladesh 31/1 off 14Sri Lanka
1-1bBangladesh 31/1 off 13Sri Lanka
1-2aBangladesh 45/1 off 15draw
1-2bBangladesh 48/2 off 13Sri Lanka
1-3aBangladesh 41/1 off 16Sri Lanka
1-3bBangladesh 44/4 off 12.3Sri Lanka
Sri Lanka 18/1 off 4
2-1aSri Lanka 34/2 off 12Bangladesh
2-1bSri Lanka 29/1 off 12Bangladesh
2-2aSri Lanka 51/0 off 16Sri Lanka
2-2bSri Lanka 43/0 off 14Sri Lanka
2-3aSri Lanka 56/0 off 15Sri Lanka
2-3bSri Lanka 63/2 off 20Bangladesh
3-1aSri Lanka 35/2 off 14Bangladesh
3-1bSri Lanka 17/2 off 4.3Bangladesh
Bangladesh 23/0 off 7
3-2aBangladesh 50/0 off 15Bangladesh
3-2bBangladesh 20/1 off 17Sri Lanka
3-3aBangladesh 35/1 off 14Sri Lanka
3-3bBangladesh 30/2 off 16Sri Lanka
4-1aBangladesh 44/3 off 12.5Sri Lanka
4-1bBangladesh 63/3 off 18.5Sri Lanka
4-2aSri Lanka 46/1 off 9.1Sri Lanka
4-2bSri Lanka 57/0 off 13.5Sri Lanka
4-3aSri Lanka 47/2 off 14Bangladesh
4-3bSri Lanka 10/0 off 4.4-

Latest update, click here
Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 15 - 7


End of match, Day 4: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 15-7

This was quite a good test match. There were two decisive things in it. First the partnership between Sangakkara and Chandimal that put Sri Lanka into a dominant position, then the bowling of Herath in the second innings. Bangladesh are certainly improving as a test team. This was a genuine match, and while Sri Lanka were the better side, they are a very good team at home. - Mykuhl

Monday 18 March 2013

Mini-session Analysis 3rd test, Ind Aus, Mohali 2013

Here is the final mini-session analysis for the third test between India and Australia at Punjab Cricket Association Stadium, Mohali, India

A mini-session is (normally) half a session, either between the start of the session and the drinks break or the drinks break and the end of the session. Occasionally a long session will have 3 mini-sessions where it will be broken up with 2 drinks breaks.

Mini-SessionScoreWinner
2-1aAustralia 48/0 off 17Australia
2-1bAustralia 61/0 off 19Australia
2-2aAustralia 36/2 off 19India
2-2bAustralia 35/1 off 17India
2-3aAustralia 57/1 off 18Australia
2-3bAustralia 36/3 off 14India
3-1aAustralia 75/1 off 20.1Australia
3-1bAustralia 60/2 off 17.4India
India 3/0 off 1
3-2aIndia 54/0 off 14India
3-2bIndia 99/0 off 14India
3-3aIndia 55/0 off 14India
3-3bIndia 72/0 off 15India
4-1aIndia 56/2 off 19Australia
4-1bIndia 45/1 off 17.1Australia
4-2aIndia 47/4 off 14.5Australia
4-2bIndia 48/0 off 16India
4-3aIndia 20/3 off 7.1Australia
4-3bAustralia 75/3 off 21India
5-1aAustralia 44/2 off 25India
5-1bAustralia 51/3 off 21India
5-2aAustralia 41/1 off 18Australia
5-2bAustralia 12/1 off 4.2India
India 30/0 off 7
5-3aIndia 58/2 off 14Australia
5-3bIndia 48/2 off 12.3India

Final update, click here
India won the match by 6 wickets and the mini-session count 14 - 10

First drinks, Day 2: Australia lead the mini-session count 1-0

There was a lot of talk before the match about the "homeworkgate" saga and the changes to Australia's middle order. However the one combination that wasn't impacted at all was the openers, and they've made a solid start here.

Middle drinks, Day 2: Australia lead the mini-session count 2-1

Michael Clarke became only the 6th batsman since 1969 to be stumped first ball. Hardly a group that he would have wanted to be part of.

Lunch, Day 3: The mini-session count is tied up, 4-4

First Smith got out for 92, then Starc joined the 99 club. It's hard not to feel very sorry for them.

Tea, Day 3: India lead the mini-session count 6-4

Someone needs to tell Shikhar Dhawan that it's a test, not an ODI match. His hundred came up off 85 balls, and featured 84 runs in boundaries.

Stumps, Day 3: India lead the mini-session count 8-4

What an amazing day for India. While the Australian tail wagged significantly, the Indian openers undid almost all the damage that Starc and Smith managed.

Middle drinks, Day 4: India lead the mini-session count 8-7

Australia delayed the new ball by 20 overs, but once they took it it had a dramatic impact. I doubt they'll make that mistake if they get another chance to bowl.

Stumps, Day 4: India lead the mini-session count 10-8

On a pitch that seems to be spinning, 11 of the 13 wickets that fell today were to pace bowlers. Interestingly only a couple of those were to balls that did something off the pitch. However the pitch does look like it might be starting to play tricks, and if Australia manage to get a lead of 180, and give themselves 50 overs, they could still very well win this match.

Lunch, Day 5: India lead the mini-session count 12-8

The Australian recovery was stymied by a couple of very dubious umpiring decisions, which again back up the BCCI's decision to not have the UDRS. Umpires inadvertently tend to give the benefit of the doubt to the team which has the momentum. It's never deliberate, but it tends to happen. Just like someone batting at number 10 seems to be much more likely to get a bad LBW decision, teams that have a reputation as struggling against spin tend to have more lbw or bat-pad decisions go against them when spinners are bowling, and likewise teams that have a reputation as having a weakness against the moving ball are more likely to have lbw or caught behind decisions go against them in conditions that suit pace.

Middle drinks, Day 5: India lead the mini-session count 12-9

Australia have almost managed to get to a defendable score. Fantastic work from the tail. Mitchell Starc looks better against spin than the majority of the Australia top order.

Stumps, Day 5: India lead the mini-session count 14-10

India have managed to win, but it was a close victory against a depleted Australian side. India will be waiting to hear how Shihkar Dhawan recovers from his hand injury, as they may have a very good partnership forming with Vijay and Dhawan. Australia will be seriously looking at the option of swapping Mitchells: Johnson for Starc. Starc seems to be in better form with the bat than the ball at the moment, which is not really what the team needs from one of their strike bowlers. The only Australian bowlers who have averaged under 60 in this series are Pattinson, Siddle and Maxwell. I think a bowling line up of Siddle, Pattinson, Lyon, Johnson and Smith looks more threatening than Siddle, Pattinson, Doherty, Lyon and Henriques personally, even with the traditionally spin friendly nature of the Kolta.

Saturday 16 March 2013

Mini-sesison Analysis, 2nd test NZ Eng, Wellington 2012/13

Here is the mini-session analysis for the second test between New Zealand and England at Basin Reserve, Wellington

A mini-session is (normally) half a session, either between the start of the session and the drinks break or the drinks break and the end of the session. Occasionally a long session will have 3 mini-sessions where it will be broken up with 2 drinks breaks.

Mini-SessionScoreWinner
1-1aEngland 44/1 off 14draw
1-1bEngland 31/0 off 14draw
1-2aEngland 56/0 off 15England
1-2bEngland 31/0 off 15draw
1-3aEngland 74/0 off 15England
1-3bEngland 31/1 off 17New Zealand
2-1aEngland 31/1 off 15draw
2-1bEngland 55/2 off 15England
2-2aEngland 52/2 off 15draw
2-2bEngland 60/3 off 11.5draw
2-3aNew Zealand 33/1 off 17England
2-3bNew Zealand 33/2 off 16England
3-1aNew Zealand 52/2 off 13England
3-1bNew Zealand 51/0 off 15New Zealand
3-2aNew Zealand 47/2 off 15England
3-2bNew Zealand 38/3 off 13.2England
3-3aNew Zealand 46/1 off 16England
3-3bNew Zealand 31/0 off 17draw
4-1aNew Zealand 32/1 off 14England
4-1bNew Zealand 44/0 off 15New Zealand
4-3aNew Zealand 9/0 off 6-

Latest update, click here
England lead the mini-session count 10 - 3

First drinks, Day 1: The mini-session count is tied up, 0-0

Some early signs of swing, but not nearly enough to justify bowling first. Both captains were going to insert the other team, so this might have been a good toss to lose. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 1: The mini-session count is tied up, 0-0

England haven't lost a wicket, but New Zealand have kept them contained. These two are biding their time, but they are not looking particularly threatened. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 1: England lead the mini-session count 1-0

This is a fantastic partnership for England here. Compton is going well in a second match in a row, which is a credit to him, as New Zealand is often a graveyard for opening batsmen. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 1: England lead the mini-session count 1-0

New Zealand have ramped up the pressure, without any reward as yet. - Mykuhl

Final drinks, Day 1: England lead the mini-session count 2-0

More solid batting. This is an outstanding partnership, which has put England into a very strong position. New Zealand once inserted the West Indies, only for them to be 270/1 at stumps. This is feeling similar. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 1: England lead the mini-session count 2-1

Not quite 270/1, but still very much England's day. The new ball bowlers just didn't have any penetration, and looked a bit tired. Hindsight is a wonderful thing, but it might have been better to save the new ball until the morning, when Southee, Boult and Wagner would be fresher. - Mykuhl

First drinks, Day 2: England lead the mini-session count 2-1

England are making very slow progress. I'm not sure if it's a deliberate thing, where they are trying to play on the fact that the New Zealand bowlers are tired, but it's certainly attritional stuff. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 2: England lead the mini-session count 3-1

While New Zealand had their most successful hour with the ball, this hour belonged to England. They started to accelerate, and losing a couple of wickets at this point is not as crippling as doing it early on day one would have been. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 2: England lead the mini-session count 3-1

England won't be unhappy with that hour, despite losing another couple of wickets. Bruce Martin has really stepped up here. The concern with Martin was that he was going to be too wayward, and bowl too many bad balls looking for wickets. He has instead bowled quite tightly, but hasn't sacrificed giving himself some opportunities to take wickets.

England scored quickly enough that they will still feel that they are in as good a position after the hour as they were before it. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 2: England lead the mini-session count 3-1

New Zealand were effective at one end, while Matt Prior owned the other end. Once he departed things wrapped up quickly. I think Prior is looking like England's best batsman at the moment. - Mykuhl

Final drinks, Day 2: England lead the mini-session count 4-1

It's not just England playing incredibly slowly. The New Zealand top 3 have been very cautious. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 2: England lead the mini-session count 5-1

That hour turned dramatically in the space of 2 balls. New Zealand looked to be building a solid platform, then Broad removed Rutherford and then bowled a peach to dismiss Ross Taylor for only his third test duck. - Mykuhl

First drinks, Day 3: England lead the mini-session count 6-1

The follow-on target is starting to look a long way off now. New Zealand need big innings from McCullum and Watling now. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 3: England lead the mini-session count 6-2

A good hour for New Zealand, they are now less than 100 from the follow on target. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 3: England lead the mini-session count 7-2

Southee is a good option at 8 when the team is on top, the bowlers are tired and NZ are looking for quick runs. I'm not sure Southee at 8 is such a good idea when the team is needing to bat time. He almost embodies the reductio ad absurdum to the "play your natural game" concept. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 3: England lead the mini-session count 8-2

New Zealand fall 11 runs short of the follow on target, and England enforce it. Bruce Martin showed some bottle at the end, but it was just not enough. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 3: England lead the mini-session count 9-2

New Zealand managed to survive the final hour, but it feels like only rain can prevent England winning this match by a large margin. - Mykuhl

First drinks, Day 4: England lead the mini-session count 10-2

The wicket of Peter Fulton made this England's hour. New Zealand will be pleased that it was just one, and not a cluster, like they have been losing in the rest of this match. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 4: England lead the mini-session count 10-3

A solid hour from Taylor and Williamson. England are losing their race against the clock. - Mykuhl

Final drinks, Day 4: England lead the mini-session count 10-3

That's probably the end of the match. The forecast is for rain tomorrow, and so this match will probably end as a damp squib. All eyes will now turn to Eden Park, hosting a test for the first time in 8 years. - Mykuhl

Mini-session Analysis 1st Test, WI Zim, Bridgetown Barbados 2013

Here is the final mini-session analysis for the first test between West Indies and Zimbabwe at Kensington Oval, Bridgetown, Barbados

A mini-session is (normally) half a session, either between the start of the session and the drinks break or the drinks break and the end of the session. Occasionally a long session will have 3 mini-sessions where it will be broken up with 2 drinks breaks.

Mini-SessionScoreWinner
1-1aZimbabwe 30/1 off 14West Indies
1-1bZimbabwe 61/1 off 13Zimbabwe
1-2aZimbabwe 38/2 off 15West Indies
1-2bZimbabwe 33/2 off 15West Indies
1-3aZimbabwe 34/1 off 15.5draw
1-3bZimbabwe 15/3 off 3.5Zimbabwe
West Indies 18/2 off 11
2-1aWest Indies 63/1 off 9.3West Indies
2-1bWest Indies 63/2 off 20.1Zimbabwe
2-2aWest Indies 73/1 off 15.2West Indies
2-2bWest Indies 48/1 off 15West Indies
2-3aWest Indies 42/3 off 13.2Zimbabwe
2-3bZimbabwe 41/3 off 14West Indies
3-1aZimbabwe 36/3 off 16West Indies
3-1bZimbabwe 30/4 off 10.2West Indies
West Indies 9/1 off 3

Final update, click here
West Indies win the match by 9 wickets and the mini-session count 9 - 4


Lunch, Day 1: The mini-session count is tied up, 1-1

A reasonable start from Mawoyo, it's good to see him hitting some form again. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 1: West Indies lead the mini-session count 3-2

When Kyle Jarvis was playing for Central Districts he produced a couple of magic spells. This is certainly a good start from him.

Lunch, Day 2: West Indies lead the mini-session count 4-3

Zimbabwe have an opening here. If they can wrap up the tail cheaply they could be back in this match.

Final drinks, Day 2: West Indies lead the mini-session count 6-4

Darren Sammy is an interesting cricketer. Not quite a batsman, not quite a bowler, and yet he's capable of turning a match with either. That was a sensational innings in the context of this match.

Stumps, Day 2: West Indies lead the mini-session count 7-4

Things are suddenly looking very grim for Zimbabwe. They desperately need a big partnership.

End of match, Day 3: West Indies lead the mini-session count 9-4

The big partnership never came. Shane Shillingford has done this to a couple of teams now, he's starting to look a little like West Indies version of Abdul Rehman, generally doesn't look particularly special, but has days where he is almost unplayable. Despite generally being good at playing spin, the Zimbabwe batsmen were all at sea against him here.

Sunday 10 March 2013

Reserve days for tests

A 4-day test match finished today, in a quite unsatisfying draw.  It was originally scheduled as a 5 day, but the entire first day was ruled out through rain, and so, according to law 13.3, the test was designated as a 4 day match, and the follow on target was reduced to 150 accordingly. 

The reason it was unsatisfying was that another days play and this could have been an epic finish, rather than a tame one.  It might have still been a draw.  But it might have been a famous win for England, after their terrible first innings, or it might have been a morale boosting win for New Zealand.

Given that there is already a precedent of the match conditions being able to be changed in a result of a days play being abandoned due to weather, I think it would be sensible for there to be a reserve day tacked on at the end of a test, and if (and only if) an entire day's play is lost, that day is designated as a rest day, and the test is extended onto the reserve day.

There have been very few 5 day draws in tests in the last 3 years.  Almost every draw has had 2 or 3 sessions lost to rain. Making an allowance for that might mean that we get a result in some of those matches.

Friday 8 March 2013

Mini-session Analysis 1st test SL Ban Galle 2013

Here is the final mini-session analysis for the first test between Sri Lanka and Bangladesh at Galle International Stadium, Galle, Sri Lanka

A mini-session is (normally) half a session, either between the start of the session and the drinks break or the drinks break and the end of the session. Occasionally a long session will have 3 mini-sessions where it will be broken up with 2 drinks breaks.

Mini-SessionScoreWinner
1-1aSri Lanka 60/0 off 11Sri Lanka
1-1bSri Lanka 72/1 off 15Sri Lanka
1-2aSri Lanka 55/1 off 15Sri Lanka
1-2bSri Lanka 60/0 off 18Sri Lanka
1-3aSri Lanka 64/1 off 17Sri Lanka
1-3bSri Lanka 50/0 off 9.3Sri Lanka
2-1aSri Lanka 32/1 off 17.3Bangladesh
2-1bSri Lanka 68/0 off 15Sri Lanka
2-2aSri Lanka 97/0 off 14Sri Lanka
2-2bSri Lanka 12/0 off 3Sri Lanka
Bangladesh 23/1 off 9
2-3aBangladesh 42/1 off 15draw
2-3bBangladesh 70/0 off 19Bangladesh
3-1aBangladesh 49/2 off 14Sri Lanka
3-1bBangladesh 40/0 off 16Bangladesh
3-2aBangladesh 61/0 off 17Bangladesh
3-2bBangladesh 45/0 off 16Bangladesh
3-3aBangladesh 56/0 off 18Bangladesh
3-3bBangladesh 52/0 off 12Bangladesh
4-1aBangladesh 45/1 off 15draw
4-1bBangladesh 63/0 off 15Bangladesh
4-2aBangladesh 43/2 off 14Sri Lanka
4-2bBangladesh 49/3 off 16Sri Lanka
4-3aSri Lanka 44/1 off 12Sri Lanka
4-3bSri Lanka 72/0 off 18Sri Lanka
5-1aSri Lanka 51/0 off 14Sri Lanka
5-1bSri Lanka 63/0 off 16Sri Lanka
5-2aSri Lanka 53/2 off 16Bangladesh
5-2bSri Lanka 52/1 off 7draw
5-3aBangladesh 51/1 off 15Bangladesh

Final update, click here
Sri Lanka take the mini-session count 16 - 10

First drinks, Day 1: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 1-0

Sri Lanka have started off with a hiss and a roar. Dilshan is treating it almost like a T20 match. This could get messy. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 1: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 2-0

A wicket fell, 72 runs were scored, but for me the highlight was when Karunaratne came back out at the fall of the first wicket. I really enjoy watching him bat, and wasn't very happy with the idea of him not being able to play. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 1: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 3-0

I have watched an entire ODI series where there was not a single innings that went at this run rate. Sri Lanka going at slightly more than a run a minute, despite Bangladesh bowling less than 14 overs per hour. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 1: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 6-0

Sri Lanka roll on. They have scored at over 4 an over, and more than a run a minute. Sangakkara was immense, as usual. When he's in Sri Lanka he is just outstanding. - Mykuhl

First drinks, Day 2: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 6-1

A good hour for Bangladesh, but it could have been a very good hour as Chandimal was dropped twice. How costly could that be. He's not a batsman that you really want to give extra chances to as he is really capable of punishing teams. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 2: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 7-1

Normal service resumes. Bangladesh spend another hour chasing leather. It might be a reflection of the quality of the bowling and batting, but this pitch doesn't seem to have offered a fair enough contest between bat and ball. With Sri Lanka having Eranga in their team and Bangladesh's batting being dominated by right handers, it might have been more sensible for the groundsman to have left some more grass on the wicket. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 2: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 8-1

It seemed like a bad idea at the time to drop Chandimal. It now seems like a very, very bad idea. Sri Lanka are giving the Bangladeshi bowlers what some people pay a dominatrix a lot of money for. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 2: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 9-1

The declaration was probably slightly earlier than normal, but 570 runs is probably going to be enough. Bangladesh are going to have to bat very well here. They are already one down, and it was Eranga that struck. He seems to have added something to his bowling in this innings, bowling a little quicker, and getting some to move in, rather than out. He may well be turning into a genuinely classy test opening bowler. Hopefully the Sri Lankan groundsmen don't work him into the ground by giving him too many mud pitches to bowl on. - Mykuhl

Final drinks, Day 2: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 9-1

It would have been Bangladesh's hour if it wasn't for the last ball where Anamul Haque was deceived by a Mendis googly. As a bowler who never quite had enough control to rely on a stock delivery, and so bowled a number of variations, I do like it when Mendis gets a wicket, especially when it's with a googly. The batsman sets up for the off break, notices that the ball's actually been delivered with a leg-break action, so adjusts, only for it to come in anyway. It's a brilliant double cross by the bowler. However, it only works if the batsman is watching closely, but not quite closely enough. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 2: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 9-2

An interesting hour there. Ashraful was going for it in order to get through to his fifty. He had 54 off 68 balls, but then went into his shell, and actually started playing like a test batsman who wanted to see out the day. He scored only 11 runs off the last 40 balls. If he continues to bat like a batsman, and has some success it might actually (finally) be the making of him. - Mykuhl

First drinks, Day 3: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 10-2

When Mahmadullah played as a bowler, the thing that really impressed me was how serious he was about his batting. He approached it like a real batsman, waiting for the right ball to hit, knowing his areas. It was something that most of the Bangladeshi batsmen couldn't really be accused of. Now that he's primarily playing as a batsman he comes down the track and has a wild heave fifth ball. I guess if he was going to bat like a batsman when he was a bowler, he probably felt he could bat like a bowler now that he is a batsman. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 3: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 10-3

Mohammad Ashraful is playing the sort of innings that we've been waiting to see. Not a swashbuckling run-a-minute flight of fancy, but a proper innings where he punishes the bad balls, and accumulates when the ball is in his area. It's all rather exciting, even if it has 45 test after he should have. I guess it's better late than never. Hopefully this innings informs how he plays from now on. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 3: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 10-4

This is good cricket from Bangladesh. They are fighting hard. Mushfiqur Rahim is a real fighter with the bat. In his last 10 innings this is the 7th time he's made it past 35. He's not prepared to throw his wicket away. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 3: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 10-5

Sri Lanka are not bowling particularly badly. They have had some bad luck, with a number of balls going past the edge. While this partnership is fantastic, it still feels like a devastating collapse is possible any second now. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 3: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 10-7

This is now Bangladesh's highest partnership, Ashraful has the highest score by any Bangladeshi batsman, and Mushfiqur Rahim is only 6 runs off second spot. Bangladesh are now in a position where they might even be able to consider declaring behind, to make Sri Lanka give them a target. They wouldn't want to do that until they have some more runs on the board, and have used up some time, but an attacking option like that may be a very good one for their future. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 4: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 14-8

Bangladesh managed to bat themselves into what looks like a no-lose position. Unfortunately it's also probably a no win position also. Perhaps the decision of the board to offer draw bonuses was a good one. Suddenly there is an incentive for their players to play for time, and, in putting a value on their wicket, they started to look like a proper test team. They still have a lot to thank the groundsman for, but they have folded on good batting tracks in the past, so it's good to see them actually applying themselves. - Mykuhl

First drinks, Day 5: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 15-8

Another hour of bowlers getting dealt to. It's not like the Sri Lankan batsmen are slogging, or going particularly crazily. It's just that they are scoring 30% faster than normal test batsmen would, and doing it without many risks. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 5: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 16-8

Another relentless hour of Sri Lanka batting. They have now scored 800 runs for the loss of 5 wickets. To put that in context, Bangladesh just had their best ever innings, and scored 638 runs for 10 wickets. If Sri Lanka keep batitng at this rate for another 14 overs then declare, Bangladesh would need to get 222 runs off 44 overs. Bangldesh have a history of crumbling in run chases, so that might be an option that Mathews might consider. Sometimes you need to use some bait if you want to catch a fish. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 5: Sri Lanka lead the mini-session count 16-9

Sri Lanka batted well in this match, but they have batted the result out of contention. Baring a miracle new ball spell from Kulasekera and Eranga, Bangladesh will hold on for a draw, but they are not going to chase this target. - Mykuhl

End of the match, Day 5: Sri Lanka take the mini-session count 16-10, but the match is drawn.

Bangladesh get a creditable draw. Sri Lanka could have made a game of it by declaring at drinks. However if they wanted to do that they should have come out and really attacked the bowling during that hour between lunch and drinks.

There's no dishonour in the draw for either team, but there are questions over both teams heading into the next match. Can Sri Lanka improve their execution, take their missed chances and find a way through the Bangladesh line-up? For Bangladesh: can they back up one good performance with another?

Whatever happens, I hope the groundsman is going to prepare a pitch with some life in it at Premadasa. - Mykuhl

Thursday 7 March 2013

Mini-session Analysis, 1st test, NZ Eng, University Oval, Dunedin 2012/3

Here is the final mini-session analysis for the first test between New Zealand and England at University Oval, Dunedin, New Zealand

A mini-session is (normally) half a session, either between the start of the session and the drinks break or the drinks break and the end of the session. Occasionally a long session will have 3 mini-sessions where it will be broken up with 2 drinks breaks.

Mini-SessionScoreWinner
2-1aEngland 35/3 off 17New Zealand
2-1bEngland 46/2 off 14New Zealand
2-2aEngland 54/3 off 17New Zealand
2-2bEngland 32/2 off 7Draw
2-3aNew Zealand 45/0 off 14New Zealand
2-3bNew Zealand 45/0 off 13New Zealand
2-3cNew Zealand 41/0 off 15New Zealand
3-1aNew Zealand 49/1 off 17Draw
3-1bNew Zealand 75/1 off 18New Zealand
3-2aNew Zealand 64/2 off 15England
3-2bNew Zealand 83/3 off 16Draw
4-1aNew Zealand 58/2 off 8.4New Zealand
4-1bEngland 29/0 off 11England
4-1cEngland 29/0 off 11England
4-2aEngland 50/0 off 17England
4-2bEngland 31/0 off 15England
4-3aEngland 49/0 off 16England
4-3bEngland 46/1 off 17New Zealand
5-1aEngland 41/1 off 18Draw
5-1bEngland 54/0 off 18England
5-2aEngland 32/1 off 13New Zealand
5-2bEngland 21/1 off 15New Zealand
5-3aEngland 39/2 off 19New Zealand

Final update, click here
New Zealand win the mini-session count 12 - 7, but the match is a draw

First drinks, Day 2: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 1-0

A commanding start by New Zealand. Cook was dropped on 9 off Boult, but it only cost 1 run, as Wagner did to England's batsmen what he's been doing to NZ domestic batsmen at this ground for 4 years now. Trott and Bell are going to have to bat well to get the initiative back. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 2: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 2-0

England started off the hour well, but a couple of breakthroughs and it was advantage New Zealand again. Boult has now bowled 9 overs for 14 runs, and had a wicket and a catch dropped. And he's probably been the least impressive of the bowlers. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 2: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 3-0

Bruce Martin didn't have a great start to his international career dropping the English Captain, but he's made up for it by dismissing Trott, Prior and Broad. It was a typical spell from Martin: some fantastic deliveries and some awful ones, but the result of it was that he's put England in more trouble. If he's causing this much trouble on a pitch like this, he might be a real handful if it starts to break up. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 2: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 3-0

The English tail scored their runs quickly, but New Zealand wrapped it up before they did too much damage. - Mykuhl

Drinks, Day 2: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 4-0

New Zealand continue their good start. Rutherford hasn't really been worked over like I was expecting, but Fulton has looked a little suspect to the ball coming back at him. However he's countered that by hitting a lot of balls on to the leg side, to encourage the bowlers to bowl outside off. It will be interesting to see when he decides to start unleashing his cover drive. At the moment he hasn't played one. - Mykuhl

Final Drinks, Day 2: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 5-0

More runs from New Zealand. They looked like they were taking it easier, but they scored faster. Rutherford brought up 50 on debut. His father got his 5oth run in his 9th innings. Quite different starts to their careers really. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 2: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 6-0

That brings to the end one of the best days in recent memory for New Zealand. England were poor all day. The wickets were often to loose shots, the bowlers struggled to hit the right lengths and they put down Rutherford twice.

Tomorrow will be interesting, as England will look to strike back. The big question will be how New Zealand respond to the increased intensity. - Mykuhl

First drinks, Day 3: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 6-0

A steady start to the day's play. New Zealand started off scoring quite freely, but once Fulton's wicket fell, Williamson made sure he didn't throw his away. The highlight was Hamish Rutherford bringing up his hundred with a drive through extra cover. There are not many better ways to do it really. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 3: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 7-0

It felt almost like there were two different games being played this hour. At one end the English bowlers had Williamson and then Taylor under some pressure. At the other end Rutherford was plundering the bowling. Rutherford scored 52 of New Zealand's 75 runs in that hour. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 3: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 7-1

England finally had the better of New Zealand in an hour. The new ball did it's job, and removed Rutherford first ball, and then Taylor departed a couple of overs before drinks. New Zealand have a lead of 152. They will want to extend that lead to be at least 250 by the end of the day. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 3: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 7-1

I combined the 5 overs after tea with this mini-session to make it long enough to be meaningful. New Zealand have pushed the lead up to 235 England took quite a few wickets, but Southee and McCullum hit their runs quite quickly and as a result tied up the hour. It feels like the race is on for this match between New Zealand and the rain. If England manage to score 400 in their second innings, New Zealand are still only going to have to chase 150. - Mykuhl

Change of innings, Day 4: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 8-1

An absolute whirlwind start by New Zealand. McCullum and Martin left no doubt as to what their intentions were. McCullum hit three of his first ten deliveries for six. Once he got out, Martin carried on swinging at almost everything. - Mykuhl

Drinks, Day 4: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 8-2

A solid start for England. Boult in particular has bowled some challenging deliveries, but so far no chances have been created. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 4: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 8-3

More good progress from the English openers. Their first objective would have been to make it to lunch. They can tick that off the list. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 4: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 8-5

Slow going this hour from England, but they still haven't lost a wicket. It's hardly T20 style cricket, but it's a test of character for both teams. - Mykuhl

Final drinks, Day 4: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 8-6

49 runs in the hour, it's good cricket from England. Martin has asked a couple of questions, particularly of Compton, and Boult has keep the batsmen under some pressure, but these two have been very solid. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 4: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 9-6

Boult got a well deserved reward for his bowling. He's taken 1/34 off 19, and 9 of those runs have been off edges. It's been England's day without a doubt. However they are still slightly behind overall. New Zealand will need to take 4 or 5 wickets before lunch tomorrow to have a realistic chance to win the game. - Mykuhl

First drinks, Day 5: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 9-6

The formula gave that hour to New Zealand, but I honestly think that the draw was a lot more likely after that hour than before. New Zealand's bowlers managed to ask a couple of questions, but they didn't bowl enough deliveries on the stumps really. On a pitch that keeps low, you need to make the batsmen pay if they miss. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 5: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 9-7

A great hour for England. They have almost worked themselves into a position where they have a sniff at winning this match. If they were to score 150 in this session, and then declare, New Zealand would be chasing 180 at 6 an over. They would certainly try it on, which might mean the England could have a chance to win the match. However that's a remote possibility, just like the chance of New Zealand winning has become almost non-existent. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 5: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 10-7

The slight glimmer of hope for England that had appeared has now dried up. New Zealand also has almost no hope of a win anymore either. The only chance for a New Zealand victory now is for 3 wickets to fall before the new ball, and then Boult and Southee to clean up the tail with the new ball. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 5: New Zealand lead the mini-session count 11-7

Steven Finn's epic resistance has finally ended, but he has well and truly done his job. He batted for longer in this test than in the rest of his career combined. It was a fantastic effort. Without him there frustrating the New Zealand bowlers, his team may have fallen over, but that's something that we'll never know. - Mykuhl

End of match, Day 5: New Zealand take the mini-session count 12-7

The English batsmen did sufficient to hold on for the draw. Prior and Bell survived the new ball, and in the process denied the New Zealand bowlers the wickets they needed to have a chance to win the game. Trent Boult had the scarcely believable figures of 1/49 off 35 overs. He doesn't really have a reputation as a particularly difficult bowler to score off, but the English batsmen were not in a mood to take risks. - Mykuhl

Wednesday 6 March 2013

Quick preview of NZ Eng match in Dunedin

I thought I'd missed the boat to do a preview of this match, but the rain has come to my rescue.

Here are a few thoughts about a couple of the match-ups I'll be looking forward to.

1. James Anderson vs Peter Fulton.

Early in Fulton's career he got out a lot to the ball leaving the bat. He had a tendency to chase it, and as a result often ended up getting out. Since he was dropped from the NZ team he has made a real effort to focus on this, and in looking through his innings over the last couple of years, I could only find 2 where he had been dismissed to this type of delivery.
However whenever a batsman makes a change to their technique there is always a question as to what new weakness it will open up. If he is looking for the one going away, then Anderson's ability to move the ball back in might be something that causes him some problems.

2. Steven Finn & Stuart Broad vs Hamish Rutherford.

There was an obvious plan in Queenstown to try and bounce Rutherford out. Finn and Broad both seem to have a tendency to try the short ball anyway, so if they sense blood they may be prone to giving Rutherford a real working over. If Rutherford is up to it, however this could give him something to attack, especially if they stray outside off, as he is very quick on the cut shot.

3. Kane Williamson vs Kane Williamson.

Can the boy wonder keep his game simple enough to play one of the innings that he's shown us previously he is capable of? Or will he get over-complicated in his approach and find another new way to get out.

4. Joe Root vs Ross Taylor.

There seems to be a theory that Ross Taylor is weak outside the off stump to off spinners. As a result Jayawardene had offies bowling outside off to him, and left a big gap for him to cut. Taylor left or defended the ball about 40 times. It will be interesting to see if Cook replicates this tactic. The extra bounce on the NZ wickets would normally mean that this wouldn't be such a good tactic, but given the instructions that the groundsman seems to have been given by the NZ camp this might be quite effective.

5. Brendon McCullum vs the media.

McCullum is walking a very tight line in terms of public perception. He's played some outstanding cricket on this tour, and yet people still somehow blame him for Ross Taylor no longer being captain. (They tend to ignore the fact that Taylor wasn't dropped as test captain, but instead chose to step down).
Even before that he was constantly under pressure. If he played his natural game (where he was generally much more successful) he was described as arrogant and irresponsible. If he played more conservatively (where he often was less successful) he was described as flaky, and not having the right temperament for test cricket. When he scores a hundred it's described as lucky, if he gets a fifty he gets criticized for not going on, and if he gets out for less than that there are calls for his head. The only way for him to win over the public is for him to play a series of outstanding innings that lead the team to victory. Perhaps if he gets his series average over 150 people might start to appreciate his contribution.

6. Monty Panesar vs Brendon McCullum.

Monty has dismissed McCullum a lot of times. In the last double-header series Panesar got McCullum 6 times. In fact, most left-armers who have bowled to McCullum have dismissed him a lot of times. Almost a quarter of his dismissals have been to left-arm spin, and they have often got him out when he was well set. Panesar will be relishing the opportunity to resume this particular battle.

7. BJ Watling vs James Anderson.

Watling dominated the 2nd string bowlers in the NZ XI match in Queenstown. He scored 66* and 89* and hardly looked troubled. Since he's put the gloves on his record is remarkable. He's scored more runs in his 5 test innings with the gloves than in the 14 previous without them. While 5 innings is hardly statistically significant, I was privileged enough to watch most of them live, and he was batting very, very well.
However in the ODI matches he came up against James Anderson, and looked significantly less assured. He faced 24 balls, scored 8 runs and was dismissed twice. The winner of that battle may well be decisive in the outcome of the match.

8. Trent Boult vs Alistair Cook.

Throughout Cook's career he has had a tendency to get out early to left arm swing bowlers. So far in Trent Boult's career he has often dismissed the most important batsman in the opposition team (in 10 tests his victims include Hussey, Amla, Kallis, Sangakkara, Tendulkar, Jayawardene and Gayle). Particularly if the ball is swinging, the Cook/Boult battle could be intriguing.

9. Tim Southee vs Nick Compton.

Compton seems to have an issue against the short pitched ball, and while Tim Southee is not express, he does have the ability to bowl a surprisingly quick bouncer. He managed to dismiss a few English batsmen with it in the Eden Park ODI match, and Compton might find himself on the end of a little chin music from Southee in this test.

10. Bruce Martin vs Kevin Pietersen.

Just like the battle between McCullum and Panesar, Pietersen has a history of getting out to left arm spin, and Bruce Martin will know that. However KP likes to dominate, and Martin has a tendency to be quite expensive, so there may be some fireworks if they get to face each other.

11. Joe Root vs Joe Root.

Root has only been dismissed once in the internationals in this tour. However he is likely to want to hold himself back a bit in the test matches. He took the foot off the accelerator in the Eden Park ODI, and immediately started to look a little more vulnerable. Good attacking players often do worse when they try to play a defensive game. How Root finds the balance between attack and defense could be vital to his success at this form of the game.

12. Neil Wagner vs Matt Prior.

Prior has a good record against left-arm pace bowlers, but he has shown a tendency to get out to bowlers who mix their pace up well. Wagner has dropped his pace a little in search of more swing, and since doing that has started to rediscover his form. He is still capable, however, of the odd ball that screams through as well as having a reasonable slower ball.
The thing that will work in Prior's favour is that his new technique is designed for pitches with less bounce, and the Dunedin wicket is likely to keep a bit low. If it starts to go up and down a bit, then Wagner might be the one with the weapons to dismiss Prior.

There are bound to be other battles arising during the match, but these 12 will be some I'm watching for.

Here's a good preview (from before the toss) with a couple of the cricket writers from the NZ Herald. I got to spend a bit of time with David Leggat while in South Africa, and was quite impressed with his ability to read the game.

Sunday 3 March 2013

CricketGeek Book Review: Chinaman: The Legend of Pradeep Mathew - Shehan Karunatilaka

As a former mystery wrist-spinner, I was eager to read the story about a Sri Lankan mystery spinner, even if he did bowl with his left arm. I was expecting a good cricket book, but instead got a very good book, that happened to feature cricket.

The book came highly recommended, and it did not disappoint. I believe that the best novels are ones that take the reader into a different time/place. I loved Crime and Punishment because when I read it I became Raskolnikov. When I read Live Bodies, I became Josef Mandl. Jane Eyre and The Bronze Horseman had a similar effect. While reading Chinaman, I was so transfixed that I could almost smell the Sri Lankan streets.

The characters have a richness that is hard to find in other novels. The three main characters all have twists and reveal new sides to themselves regularly. The lead character, WG Karunasena, undertakes a moral journey that would feel at home in a Dostoyevsky novel.

Often books with exceptionally deep characters sacrifice the plot. While there was moments where the book dragged, it generally moved quite quickly, and some of the twists in the plot were both unexpected and interesting.

Overall this is one of the best books I've ever read. The three books that it feels the most like are three of my favourites, A Painted House by John Grisham, Mr Pip by Lloyd Jones and Live Bodies by Maurice Gee. I cannot recommend it highly enough.

Mini-session Analysis, 2nd test, Ind Aus, Hyderabad 2013

Here is the final mini-session analysis for the second test between India and Australia at Rajiv Gandhi International Stadium, Hyderabad, India

A mini-session is (normally) half a session, either between the start of the session and the drinks break or the drinks break and the end of the session. Occasionally a long session will have 3 mini-sessions where it will be broken up with 2 drinks breaks.

Mini-SessionScoreWinner
1-1aAustralia 49/2 off 13India
1-1bAustralia 34/2 off 15India
1-2aAustralia 46/0 off 14Australia
1-2bAustralia 58/0 off 18Australia
1-3aAustralia 30/2 off 13.5India
1-3bAustralia 20/3 off 11.1India
India 5/0 off 3
2-1aIndia 26/1 off 13Australia
2-1bIndia 23/0 off 14draw
2-2aIndia 52/0 off 14India
2-2bIndia 54/0 off 19India
2-3aIndia 94/0 off 16India
2-3bIndia 57/0 off 14India
3-1aIndia 45/0 off 16India
3-1bIndia 44/2 off 14Australia
3-2aIndia 56/1 off 15India
3-2bIndia 47/6 off 16.1Australia
3-3aAustralia 53/0 off 16Australia
3-3bAustralia 21/2 off 16India
4-1aAustralia 37/3 off 15.2India
4-1bAustralia 20/5 off 19.4India

Final update, click here
India take the mini-session count 13 - 6

First drinks, Day 1: India lead the mini-session count 1-0

Bhuvneshwar Kumar was the star, having gone wicket-less in his debut test. He uprooted Warner’s leg stump in his second over and then trapped Cowan lbw not long after, although replays showed the ball had pitched just outside leg.

Watson and Hughes survived till drinks – Watson playing with considerable assurance, Hughes less so. - PaulADennett

Lunch, Day 1: India lead the mini-session count 2-0

India are well on top now. Outstanding bowling by Bhuvneshwar Kumar and R Ashwin to set the game up well for India. Australia will be glad that they picked an extra batsman in this test. The hope for Australia will be in the ease with which Michael Clarke came down the wicket to hit Ashwin back over his head for 6. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 1: India lead the mini-session count 2-1

Another Michael Clarke rescue job. Someone on cricinfo suggested that Australia should try to bat him at 3, 4 and 5. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 1: The mini-session count is tied up, 2-2

Fantastic innings from Wade here. He's been under some pressure, and is responding to it well. - Mykuhl

Final drinks, Day 1: India lead the mini-session count 3-2

It was going to be interesting to see how Henriques backed up. Unfortunately for him, he got a good one early and as a result is heading back to the shed. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 1: India lead the mini-session count 4-2

Stephen Fleming was a fan of the declaration 9 down, although he had Chris Martin in his side regularly, so there wasn't a significant difference between being 9 down and all out. Clarke here has taken a small gamble, and while it hasn't paid off, it's still admirable captaincy. The opportunity to bowl 3 overs at the end of the day, and give his bowlers two bites of the cherry was worth the cost. Traditionally the final wicket has provided 4% of a team runs, so realistically Clarke cost his team about 8 runs for a better chance to dismiss an opener. That's a gamble worth taking. - Mykuhl

First drinks, Day 2: India lead the mini-session count 4-3

An early breakthrough and some very disciplined bowling from Australia gives them this first hour. They are fighting back into this test. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 2: India lead the mini-session count 4-3

While the Indian batsmen scored very little, they both survived. India are going at less than 2 an over, which is a product of both a conservative approach from the Indian batsmen, but also some tight bowling by Australia. Henriques in particular has been very demanding. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 2: India lead the mini-session count 5-3

The two Indian batsmen have started to open up now. They waited until the bowlers started to tire, and then punished any bad ball. It's good test batting, almost from a different age. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 2: India lead the mini-session count 6-3

Pujara and Vijay are doing exactly the right thing here. They are in a match position where they can afford to play each ball on it's merits. This batting has, to a degree, been made possible by the good work with the ball, meaning that they are not under any scoreboard pressure. - Mykuhl

Final drinks, Day 2: India lead the mini-session count 7-3

These two are relentless at the moment. Australia are in significant trouble. I am still struggling to understand why they went for Maxwell over Lyon. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 2: India lead the mini-session count 8-3

This is an exhibition of batting. These two are closing in on some big milestones. They are 51 runs away from being the highest 2nd wicket partnership for India, and from there another 32 runs away from the largest partnership for any wicket for India vs Australia. 89 more runs and they are the highest partnership against Australia by anyone. That's still a long way away and they have to survive the first hour that is likely to be testing, but these two have batted India into a dominant position. - Mykuhl

First drinks, Day 3: India lead the mini-session count 9-3

The big moment in this hour was the lbw shout against Che Pujara from a ball that pitched on middle and beat the bat by Doherty. Other than that it has been plain sailing for the batsmen.

I wanted to look at the Hawkeye replay of that ball, but unsurprisingly BCCI TV haven't played it as yet. Generally that implies that the ball was going to hit the stumps. - Mykuhl

Lunch, Day 3: India lead the mini-session count 9-4

Finally Australia have something go their way. And it was a double breakthrough. People often say things like "When one falls, the other often falls soon after." While that's been statistically proven to be not true, occasions like this make it feel true. Australia are hardly "back in the game" but they did win that hour. - Mykuhl

Middle drinks, Day 3: India lead the mini-session count 10-4

It looks like Dhoni wants another double century, but also wants to declare tonight. He's raced through to 43. The key moment was the dismissal of Tendulkar. It is unclear what happened in between the umpires, but somehow Tendulkar was given, and probably correctly too. - Mykuhl

Tea, Day 3: India lead the mini-session count 10-5

The final 9 wickets fell for 116 runs. The first one fell for 17. It was the 370 runs that happened between the first and second wicket that made this an awesome innings. - Mykuhl

Final drinks, Day 3: India lead the mini-session count 10-6

A very good start for Australia. In order to have a famous come-from-behind victory you first need a terrible start. They certainly have the first part sorted out. - Mykuhl

Stumps, Day 3: India lead the mini-session count 11-6

It's very easy to criticize a batsman for getting out bowled round his legs to a finger spinner. It's much harder to defend them for it. There is nothing wrong with sweeping a ball outside leg stump, provided you cover your stumps. If a batsman can play the shot properly, it is a fantastic shot. But if a batsman gets bowled round his legs, it's clear that he can't play the shot properly and therefore he shouldn't be experimenting with it when his team is 200 runs behind. One big partnership could open this match up, but that won't happen if batsmen try stupid shots that they haven't practiced in the nets. - Mykuhl

First drinks, Day 4: India lead the mini-session count 12-6

India dominated this session, and it could have been even more dramatic. There was a catch down the leg side that was hardly even appealed for, and a lbw that looked pretty good, but wasn't given. Australia are looking square in the eyes of an innings defeat. - Mykuhl

End of match, Day 4: India win the match by an innings and 135 runs, and the mini-session count 13-6

A convincing win by India, but back to the drawing board for Australia. They've become only the 11th team to lose a match after declaring the first innings closed, and the first to ever lose by an innings after declaring. This match was completely dominated by one partnership, with Pujara and Vijay putting on more runs than either their team mates combined or both of Australia's innings combined. If it wasn't for those two, this might have been a close match. But that's a bit like saying that if it wasn't for their three great sprinters, Jamaica might not have won the mens 100m Olympic gold medal. India won this match because they played much better cricket. The conditions here were less suited to India than the conditions at Chennai were, and yet India were more dominant in this match than in the last one. - Mykuhl

Friday 1 March 2013

Batting first in ODIs revisited

Ravi Bopara - better batting second
My first ever post on this blog was about the benefits of batting or fielding in ODI matches. There's been over 2 years pass since that article so I though it was time to look back and revise the numbers. It's also interesting to see if any of the trends have changed with the innovations in the game in the last 2 years.

I've had to change my criteria somewhat as this search is over roughly 2 years, rather than 3, and hasn't included world cup qualifiers, so a lot of teams have played significantly fewer games. As a result I decided to look at any team who had played at least 15 matches. It means that the results for Ireland, Zimbabwe and Bangladesh are not quite as significant as I would have liked, due to the small sample sizes. However, it's better to have them in, and be able to draw conclusions than to not have them there at all.

Here are the numbers:

TeamMatchesW/L BattingW/L FieldingW/L Ratio
England 530.782.000.39
New Zealand 380.641.160.55
Bangladesh 290.420.720.58
Sri Lanka 660.751.280.59
Australia 601.572.330.67
South Africa 311.281.800.71
India 581.441.900.76
Pakistan 521.552.000.78
West Indies 530.640.760.84
Zimbabwe 230.370.331.12
Ireland 160.800.501.60

If the results were emphatic last time, they are remarkably so now. No team who has played more than 23 matches has a better record batting first than fielding first. Of the top 8, only West Indies does not have a winning record when bowling first.

New Zealand and England are the two teams that have the biggest difference between batting and fielding, so it's unsurprising that in the recent series every game was won by the team batting second.

The question also arises, is the difference due to the batting or the bowling. Are teams better at batting second, or are they better at bowling first. To assess this I looked at the whole team batting index for each team batting first and second.

TeamMatchesBatting firstBatting secondRatio
Bangladesh 2916.0023.340.69
Australia 6026.8533.890.79
England 5328.0632.640.86
Ireland 1620.9123.350.90
Sri Lanka 6625.6028.580.90
West Indies 5321.9224.020.91
Pakistan 5223.3025.410.92
New Zealand 3828.0227.391.02
India 5834.4230.281.14
South Africa 3132.7126.481.24
Zimbabwe 2323.8718.381.30

We can see that New Zealand and South Africa are both actually better at batting in the first innings, despite being better at winning when batting second. This is very interesting, as it implies that for these teams the big difference is not the batting, but rather the bowling. Most teams are still better at batting second, but the difference isn't nearly as profound.

It also made me wonder about the batsmen. Who had the biggest difference between batting first and second in the last couple of years. I looked at every batsman who had scored at least 200 runs in each innings during the time period. As a result I found the batsmen who favoured each innings the most.

Bating first:
NameBatting 1stBatting 2ndRatio f/s
V Sehwag (India) 101.3614.866.82
SR Tendulkar (India) 52.2822.422.33
RA Jadeja (India) 35.6016.322.18
JH Kallis (SA) 39.3618.712.10
MS Dhoni (India) 70.6234.192.07
IJL Trott (Eng) 49.9027.221.83
BRM Taylor (Zim) 48.0229.591.62
JP Duminy (SA) 39.7024.521.62
Mushfiqur Rahim (Ban) 31.8119.851.60
Mohammad Hafeez (Pak) 30.6119.531.57
Younis Khan (Pak) 27.7319.361.43
HM Amla (SA) 58.6541.511.41
HDRL Thirimanne (SL) 27.7719.811.40
LRPL Taylor (NZ) 46.0932.981.40
KA Pollard (WI) 34.2625.761.33

Batting second:

NameBatting 1stBatting 2ndRatio s/f
RS Bopara (Eng) 15.9345.582.86
SR Watson (Aus) 28.4974.072.60
AJ Strauss (Eng) 22.2352.432.36
MJ Guptill (NZ) 22.5752.072.31
V Sibanda (Zim) 19.2039.172.04
Misbah-ul-Haq (Pak) 21.8944.002.01
RR Sarwan (WI) 18.6336.451.96
F du Plessis (SA) 18.1932.921.81
MN Samuels (WI) 18.6233.621.81
Shakib Al Hasan (Ban) 20.7036.611.77
EJG Morgan (Eng) 28.6147.121.65
AB de Villiers (SA) 64.6298.641.53
V Kohli (India) 35.9053.501.49
LD Chandimal (SL) 20.0828.381.41
DJ Bravo (WI) 15.2421.421.41

There is a theory that it takes a lot of experience to learn how to bat well in the first innings. Having Sehwag, Tendulkar and Kallis all in the top 4 probably backs that up. The numbers put up by Sehwag in the first innings are extraordinary. He's scored 655 runs, at an average over 80 and a strike rate over 120.

While the adage might be that 9 times out of 10 you should bat, the truth is that it's probably more sensible to have a bowl.